Difference between terrorism and insurgency compare the. This normative principle relating to a state of war between two countries can be extended without difficulty to a conflict between a nongovernmental organization and a state. Guerrilla warfare, occurring between lightly armed partisans and a conventional army, is an example of asymmetrical warfare. Do you know the difference between terrorism and guerrilla. I gotta fundamentally take issue with the question that there is a difference between terrorism and guerilla warfare. He seeks answers to such questions as the genesis and context of an insurgency and what factors are common to many conflicts. In this paper, i will try to analyze the key elements of terrorism and guerrilla warfare. Distinguishing terrorism from guerrilla warfare the ornery. Another difference is the intent of the component activities and operations of insurgencies versus terrorism. Unconventional warfare pocket guide the purpose of this document is to provide a pocket reference of unconventional warfare uw doctrine, concepts, academic inquiry, and suggested supplementary reading for military leaders and planners. An epic history of guerrilla warfare from ancient times to the present, new. According to this definition, terrorism is premeditated, politically motivated violence.
Doctrinally, we dod define terrorism as the calculated use of violence or threat of. Terrorist tactics, such as hijackings and suicide bombings, are also considered to be asymmetrical, both because they tend to involve a smaller, weaker group attacking a stronger one and also because attacks on civilians. Drawing a distinction between guerrilla warfare and terrorism, the author focuses on guerrilla activity. Terrorism, insurrection, and guerrilla warfare by justin king september 1, 2016 washington, dc tfc due to the continued plunge into the war on terror and the different conflicts the west has started, become involved with, or prolonged. The best books on terrorism recommended by mary habeck. According to a book by harvey kushner and bart davis, islamic extremist groups have been. Question do you know the difference between terrorism and g. Guerrilla warfare is a sustained fight using unconventional tactics a lot of hit and run style stuff, with abductions. Why were guerrilla warfare and acts of terrorism rare in history. I will not give a historical overview, but my aim will be to reach a theoretical description that includes the crucial features of the two treated forms of violence.
What is the difference between terrorism and guerrilla. The definition of unconventional warfare and the scope of uw activities has long been disputed witty, 2010 according to the department of defense dictionary of military terms j oint pub 102 the cu rrent definition of uw, approved by ussocom in 2009, is activities conducted to enable a resistance movement or insurgency to coerce, disrupt, or overthrow a government or occupying power. The difference between guerrilla warfare and terrorism. In some cases, the use of terrorism can be an aspect of guerrilla warfare. They say that insanity is repeating the same mistakes over and over while expecting a different. Terrorism is easily the most contentious and elusive type of violence to define.
Sep 09, 2008 the distinction between terrorism and guerilla warfare is that there is no distinction. When the green berets were established in the 1950s, army leaders recognized that the fight against soviet communism would involve counter. Some analysts theorists agree, but confusion remains. In such contexts, fear is a paramount feature of social action. What is the difference between guerrilla style warfare and. The cases study american participation as the guerrillas, fighting the guerrillas.
About unconventional warfare uw ussocom library at. The professor of strategic studies at johns hopkins university picks five books you must read to understand the war on terror, starting with one that tries to define what terrorism is. The book draws upon guevaras personal experience as a guerrilla soldier during the cuban revolution, generalizing for readers. Guerrilla warfare can also be called competition between opponents of unequal strength. By revolting against the repressive regimes of the british monarchies, insurgent action led to harsh repercussions against the colonists, leading to the declaration of independence and the revolutionary war. Guerrilla warfare is unconventional and asymmetrical. However, there are several critical differences in how modern guerrilla. Distinguishing terrorism from guerrilla warfare the.
This sets it apart from both guerilla warfare and terrorism, as they are both methods available to pursue the goals of the political movement. In 217 bc, roman dictator quintus fabius maximus, often called the father of guerrilla warfare, used his fabian strategy to defeat the mighty invading army of carthaginian general hannibal barca. Some people think that terrorism and criminal violence is the same type. Understanding this difference is critical before beginning a discussion of how to counter insurgent movements. The term terrorism is used interchangeably with other terms, like guerrilla warfare and. In this assignment, you will examine the difference between terrorism and guerrilla warfare from a historical standpoint. Turning back to mao zedong, one may see a major difference between what may be referred to as guerrillaism, and textbook terrorism or guerrilla warfare. The media does a poor job of differentiating between terrorism and guerrilla warfare. European style warfare is when the army stands in one big line with row after row of soldier. Guerrilla warfare is a form of irregular warfare in which small groups of combatants, such as paramilitary personnel, armed civilians, or irregulars, use military tactics including ambushes, sabotage, raids, petty warfare, hitandrun tactics, and mobility, to fight a larger and lessmobile traditional military.
Defining terrorism is one mans terrorist another mans. In the book, america and guerrilla warfare, anthony james joes examines and draws conclusions from nine cases of american involvement with guerrilla style warfare. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. This is not entirely surprising, since guerrillas often employ the same tactics assassination, kidnapping, bombings of public gatheringplaces, hostagetaking, etc. The idea of dynamic insurgencies was previously developed by mao zadong. Are illegitimate acts against an enemy in war terrorism, war crimes, or is there a difference. Terrorism while they both employ many of the same tactics and weapons, there are important differences between guerrilla fighters and terrorists. Insurgency, counterinsurgency and guerrilla warfare 64 books.
It is a fact that, in modern times, there are always people and groups in societies who feel aggrieved with the policies and programs of those in authority and strive to achieve freedom for themselves by staging a rebellion. On the one hand, a possible connection between them has to be investigated, and, on the. This is typically a war between a standing, professional army and an insurgency or resistance movement militias who often have status of unlawful combatants. Difference between terrorism and guerrilla warfare from a. Terrorism vs guerrilla warfare archive straight dope.
Difference between terrorism and guerrilla warfare. The best example to show the contrast between guerrilla warfare and terrorism would be viet cong during the vietnam war and, quite obviously, al qaeda in the 911 attacks. Terrorism is used to focus international attention on the guerrilla cause, kill opposition leaders, extort money from targets, intimidate the general population, create economic losses, and keep followers and potential defectors in line. Strategy and tactics of guerrilla warfare wikipedia. When we compare institutional, ideational, and individual explanations for violence, we generally find that. In the guerrilla struggle, military personnel and facilities are targeted in line with political goals, but in case of terrorist actions.
Guerrilla groups are a type of violent nonstate actor. What walter gave to the world in both books was the first systematic treatment of. Terrorists though distinguishing between guerrillas, insurgents, and terrorists may seem like a purely academic exercise, deeper analysis may reveal some extremely pragmatic understandings to help in combating each. The guerrilla force is largely or entirely organized in small units that are dependent on the support of the local population. Assignment guidelines searching the internet, research the 1996 terrorist attack against the khobar towers in saudi arabia. Jul 15, 2004 in the book, america and guerrilla warfare, anthony james joes examines and draws conclusions from nine cases of american involvement with guerrilla style warfare. Guerrillas compose of a certain number of militant groups, acting as a military unit and thus take the name of paramilitary forces or combatants. Revolutionary and counter revolutionary terrorism in. Terrorist tactics, such as hijackings and suicide bombings, are also considered to be asymmetrical, both because they tend to involve a smaller, weaker group attacking a stronger one and also because attacks on civilians are by definition oneway warfare. The difference between counterterrorism and counterinsurgency is simple. What is the difference between guerrilla and traditional warfare.
Asymmetric warfare or asymmetric engagement is war between belligerents whose relative military power differs significantly, or whose strategy or tactics differ significantly. Guerrilla warfare, as practiced by the spanish against napoleons occupation force, illustrates the difference between guerrilla warfare and revolutionary warfare. This solution is an explanation for students who have an interest in military history of the differences between counterforce conflict and guerrilla warfare. Most importantly, terrorists rarely attack defended military targets. In his book, mao described guerrilla warfare as a pyramidal process divided. Terrorism and guerrilla warfare often serve as alternative designations of the same phenomenon. The differences between the guerrilla warfare and terrorism. The first row fires and then ducks down to reload while the row behind them fires and so on. Insurgency, counterinsurgency and guerrilla warfare score a book s total score is based on multiple factors, including the number of people who have voted for it and how highly those voters ranked the book. Irregular warfare, which is different in form but warfare nonetheless, describes types of violence conducted by substate actors including terrorism and insurgency. Guerrilla warfare is a form of irregular warfare in which small groups of combatants, such as paramilitary personnel, armed civilians, or irregulars, use military tactics including ambushes, sabotage, raids, petty warfare, hit and run tactics, and mobility, to fight a larger and lessmobile traditional military. All bona fide liberation movements are invariably described as terrorists 2.
The troubles between england and ireland are centuries old. The main strategy and tactics of guerrilla warfare tend to involve the use of a small attacking, mobile force against a large, unwieldy force. What is the difference between gorilla and guerrilla. This leads to a difference of opinion regarding cooperation between guerrilla and regular forces. The term terrorism, however, has a far more negative connotation, seemingly requiring one to take a stand, whereas the term guerrilla warfare is perceived as neutral and carries a more positive connotation. This content was copied from view the original, and get the alreadycompleted solution here. Guerrillaism combines the essence of guerrilla warfare and terrorism because it involves both quick grassroots violent attacks and a broader and coercive political and military agenda. Guerrilla warfare is a form of irregular warfare in which small groups of combatants, such as. Terrorism is aimed toward civilian targets and guerrilla warfares prime concentration is militarytype objectives. Insurgency distinguished from rebellion, guerrilla warfare, and civil war. And this is because in many respects terrorism is used interchangeably with other popular terms, such as guerrilla warfare or insurgency. America and guerrilla warfare analyzes conflicts in which americans have participated in the role. The crucial difference between physical and psychological.
As some have mentioned, terrorism is a label for a type of warfare that is intrinsically objectionable to the opposition, where the opposition generally has conventional military forces. In a book from several years ago,1 i outlined the complexity of. In this regard it is little different from the early book edited by robert carmack in 1988. Within the field many scholars do seek to differentiate between these two phenomena. The cases study american participation as the guerrillas, fighting the guerrillas, lending support too and against the guerrilla forces. Such governments, as the authors of a book about latin american state terrorism have noted, can virtually paralyze a society through violence and its threat. Whats the difference between the guerrilla warfare. It has to be kept in mind that the insurgency is performed by people who are not recognized as belligerents. Sep 24, 2012 it is a fact that, in modern times, there are always people and groups in societies who feel aggrieved with the policies and programs of those in authority and strive to achieve freedom for themselves by staging a rebellion. What is the difference between terrorism and guerrilla warfare. The use of the diminutive evokes the differences in number, scale, and scope between. How to define terrorism sinai perspectives on terrorism.
What is the difference between counterinsurgency and counter. The main difference between terrorism and guerrilla warfare is that guerrilla warfare targets state actors. What is the difference between counterinsurgency and. What is the relationship between religion and terrorism. The distinction between terrorism and guerilla warfare is that there is no distinction. Mao clearly sees regular forces as a vital part of the campaign, declaring that an attempt to use only irregular forces to win a war, exaggerates the importance of guerrilla hostilities tsetung, 1961, p. What is the similarities between insurgency and guerrilla. Yet they all have profound similarities, which accounts for this common usage. It is very difficult to define both guerrilla warfare and terrorism. Definitions of terrorism also vary as to whether terrorism includes attacks against only noncombatant targets see dos definition. The viet cong used different traps and methods to individually attack the members of the us army so they can slowly exhaust their forces.
Terrorism and guerrilla insurgency essay 2378 words cram. Published in 1961 following the cuban revolution, it became a reference for thousands of guerrilla fighters in various countries around the world. Terrorism is often confused or equated with, or treated as synonymous with, guerrilla warfare. Conflating terrorism and insurgency cato institute. This book mainly covers the theoretical and strategic aspects of guerrilla warfare, the need for complete political clarity at all levels, strict ethical codes and internal discipline for the men, and the proposed use of guerrillas against a qualitatively superior but numerically inferior force tasked with occupation and pacification. Dec 21, 2010 the difference between counter terrorism and counterinsurgency is simple. Are illegitimate acts against an enemy in war terrorism, war crimes, or is there even a. The intended purpose of both forms is the destruction of life and liberty, notwithstanding any disparity in the number of casualties at the end of the day. Conflict and its application for the future 68 to revolution and the current world structure. They live in africa, and all gorilla species are on the iucn red list as in danger of extinction this is a or rather the guerrilla ernesto che guevara, he is the guy who wrote the book for guerrilla war. Tactically, the guerrilla army makes the repetitive attacks far from the opponents center of gravity with a view to keeping. Guerrilla warfare an overview sciencedirect topics. A history of insurgency, terrorism, and guerrilla war, from the american revolution to iraq polk, william r. Guerrilla warfare and terrorism library binding april 1, 1977 by stephen goode author visit amazons stephen goode page.
A history of insurgency, terrorism, and guerrilla war. This is typically a war between a standing, professional army and an insurgency or resistance movement militias who often have status of unlawful combatants asymmetric warfare can describe a conflict in which the. Guerrilla warfare uses surprise attacks from hidden positions, often with only a few skilled soldiers. The use of guerrilla warfare was first suggested in the 6th century bc by chinese general and strategist sun tzu, in his classic book, the art of war. In essence, guerrilla warfare is not symbolic but rather devoted to a certain aim by contrast to terrorism where violence is a tool and symbol. No matter how much people strained the definition of terrorism. Guerrilla warfare lets turn to the last reason why its so difficult to define terrorism. Mar 10, 2004 turning back to mao zedong, one may see a major difference between what may be referred to as guerrillaism, and textbook terrorism or guerrilla warfare.
431 865 4 1152 1488 1256 492 751 958 1256 160 29 26 21 62 724 680 1258 282 688 32 1243 1444 66 241 1495 1427 56 764 1274 288 1480 965 841 444 618 1295 1028 1470 1303 266 781 722 429 104 995 1385